| Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Studio album by Ry Cooder | ||||
| Released | August 30, 2011 | |||
| Recorded | 2010–11 Drive-By Studios (North Hollywood, California) Ocean Studios (Burbank, California) Wireland Studios (Chatsworth, California) |
|||
| Genre | Americana, roots | |||
| Length | 61:17 | |||
| Label | Nonesuch | |||
| Producer | Ry Cooder | |||
| Ry Cooder chronology | ||||
|
||||
| Singles from Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down | ||||
|
||||
Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down is the fourteenth studio album by American recording artist Ry Cooder, released August 30, 2011, on Nonesuch Records. It was written and produced by Cooder and recorded at Drive-By Studios, Ocean Studios, and Wireland Studios in California. Inspired by the late-2000s economic crisis and past protest songs, the album features topical songs about socio-political subject matter in 21st-century America, including politics, war, economic disparity, and social injustice. Its music is rooted in Americana and incorporates traditional styles and musical language from historical sources such as country blues, tejano, and American roots music. The album has been noted by music writers for its eclectic musical range, allegorical songs, working-class perspective, and Cooder's sardonic lyrics.
The album's first and only single, "Quicksand", was released as a digital download, with the proceeds of its sales subsequently being donated to the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund. Although it charted modestly in the United States, the album attained relatively higher charting in European countries, including Ireland, the United Kingdom, and Norway, where it reached its highest chart position. Upon its release, Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down received general acclaim from music critics, who praised its diverse sound, trenchant commentary, and Cooder's musicianship. Several critics drew comparisons of Cooder to singer-songwriter and folk musician Woody Guthrie. It was nominated for a Grammy Award for Best Americana Album, set to be presented at the 54th Grammy Awards in 2012.
Contents |
The album follows Cooder's 2008 album I, Flathead and his work on The Chieftains' 2010 album San Patricio.[1] It was inspired by the late-2000s economic crisis and past protest songs.[2] In interviews prior to the album's release, Cooder expressed strong anti-Republican and anti-banker sentiments in discussion about the political and economic climate.[3] Before conceiving the album, he wrote and recorded the song "Quicksand" in 2010, as a response to the controversy spurred by Arizona Senate Bill 1070 and anti-illegal immigration measure in the United States.[4] In an interview for The Australian, he said of his decision to pursue a more political direction with his songwriting, "I was still working on the Flathead record; that was during [George] Bush's time. I was looking at things and paying attention to events, politically. So I started trying to write political songs because it's good to have something you can do other than just sit and fume about everything. After Barack Obama got elected I started thinking about other stories that might be good to do. It occurred to me that the social and political problems that we've been having, well [...] it's deja vu all over again, as the man said."[5]
In early 2011, Cooder was inspired to write the song "No Banker Left Behind", and subsequently the rest of the album, by a headline about bankers and other affluent people who had profited from the bank bailouts and resulting recession during the late-2000s.[1] In an interview with Kai Ryssdal on Marketplace, Cooder cited the song as the starting point for writing the album and stated, "'No Banker Left Behind' originated with a line from Robert Scheer's Truthdig blog. I read this pretty regularly, and when I saw this, this metric I thought 'no banker left behind.'"[2] He compared the album's content to Woody Guthrie's songs about the Dust Bowl era during the Great Depression and said of his own songs, "What I like in the idea of these songs is if you follow the logic of each tune — this happened and this happened and you can see that at the end, this is the result, you just didn't see it this way before, you never thought of Wall Street in terms of Jesse James and bilingual heft."[2]
Recording sessions for the album took place at Drive-By Studios in North Hollywood, Ocean Studios in Burbank, and Wireland Studios in Chatsworth, California.[6] The album was written and produced entirely by Cooder, except "Lord Tell Me Why", which was co-written by session drummer Jim Keltner.[7] Cooder also worked with vocalist Juliette Commagere, accordionist Flaco Jiménez, bassist Robert Francis, vocalist Arnold McCuller,[7] and drummer Joachim Cooder, Cooder's son.[8] Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down was mixed by Martin Pradler and mastered by recording engineer Bernie Grundman at his Hollywood studio Grundman Mastering.[7] Most of the album was engineered in Pradler's living room.[9]
The album's music is rooted in Americana and draws on styles such as blues, folk, ragtime, norteño, rock, and country music.[8] For the songs, Cooder adapted musical language from historical sources and incorporated styles from both North and South American traditions.[3][10] In his interview on Marketplace, he explained his stylistic approach for Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down, stating "to me, these musical styles and sounds are narratives as well. I mean everything about them — if it's an accordion, horns, the banda horns for the immigrant tunes — they all are part of the story. And you can see it then, you can imagine the Arizona border that's hot, 120 degrees in the shade, dusty. The banda horns are coming from some truck over there."[2] According to him, musical settings for certain songs were decided based on their respective compositions, such as when "the words would come to me in ¾ time, that meant corrido, that means accordion; banda horns because they’re exciting."[9]
Cooder wanted the music of each song to complement the stories and to serve as homages to particular traditional styles.[9] Cooder said that he did not want to "over-think it" and said of his creative process for each song's distinct style, "It’s taken a long time, but it becomes natural to combine an idea you have or a story you want to tell with whatever seems conducive."[9] Graham Reid of The New Zealand Herald writes that the music "refers to the dustbowl era, rural blues, Tex-Mex (with accordionist Flaco Jimenez) and old-time folk."[11] The Observer's Neil Spencer comments that it is "grounded in the blues, folk and Tex-Mex the guitarist explored in the 1970s, but its songs belong to modern times."[12]
Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down features socio-political themes of power and its abuses, the struggle for democracy, the trials of the working class, and the goal of equality, with songs composed as either first-person narratives or allegories.[9][13] The songs deal with contemporary subject matter and topics such as immigration legislation, the emotional and physical effects of war, the dubiousness of politics, social class and race division, and white flight.[9] Cooder's songwriting is characterized by sardonic lyrics, satire,[14] mordant humor,[15] and wry observations on figures such as bankers, politicians, and militarists.[16] Nick Cristiano of The Philadelphia Inquirer writes of his lyrics, "Cooder takes deadly aim at rapacious bankers, warmongers, land barons, and the like, showing the devastating impact of their actions on ordinary folk", adding that "He does this in a manner that mixes the scrappy populism of Woody Guthrie with the first-person narratives of Springsteen in Steinbeckian Ghost of Tom Joad mode."[15] Robin Denselow of The Guardian notes "bleak or thoughtful lyrics [set] against jaunty melodies" and "no elaborate narratives" in the songs, while interpreting the album's motif to be that of "a broken, divided society and the gap between rich and poor, but with the anger matched against humour."[17] Allmusic's Steve Huey writes that the album "reache[s] all the way back to his earliest recordings for musical inspiration while telling topical stories about corruption — political and social — the erasure and the rewriting of American history, and an emerging class war."[1]
Neil Spencer of Uncut calls the album "an impassioned portrait of 21st century America and its injustices", adding that "like Guthrie, [Cooder] nails his targets with droll humour while empathising with society's underdogs."[18] Allmusic's Thom Jurek characterizes it as "overtly political" and comments that "the depth of Cooder's rage is quieter but more direct as the album draws to a close."[8] Peter Kane of Q compares it to Cooder's 1971 studio album Into the Purple Valley, which featured Dust Bowl-era songs, and writes that Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down's "protest songs for today's messed-up world" are "sly and humorous".[19] On its themes, journalist Alec Wilkinson compares the album to Cooder's previous trilogy of Los Angeles-themed albums, which compromised Chávez Ravine (2005), My Name Is Buddy (2007), and I, Flathead (2008).[20] Wilkinson stated, "What 'Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down' shares with them is an indignation over the economic and ethical disparities of American life and the destructive and scoundrely meanness of the privileges given to the rich."[20] Philip Majorins of PopMatters compares the album to other American songwriters' "substantial statements" about the American zeitgeist, including Randy Newman's Harps and Angels (2008), Paul Simon's So Beautiful or So What (2011), and Bob Dylan's Modern Times (2006).[21] However, Majorins distinguishes Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down as "an attempt at the existential, providing an everyman's view of struggle during economic downturn, class disparity, injustice, and abuse of power", and he calls Cooder "a direct voice of protest, both musically and lyrically, that will not be mistaken for being impressionistic."[21]
The opening track "No Banker Left Behind" references the financial bailout of 2007 and criticizes bankers and government.[8][14] Alec Wilkinson of The New Yorker writes that the song "ridicules the considerations extended to the prosperous men and women who grabbed everything not nailed down during the last few years."[20] It features marching rhythms, mandolin and banjo riffs, and electric guitar.[8] Cooder has described the song's rhythm as "a kind of clog-dance beat".[2] "El Corrido Jesse James" is played in waltz time with a horn section and accordion by Flaco Jiménez.[8] The lyrics express a fictitious narrative by American outlaw Jessie James in Heaven, who claims to have never "turned a family from their house" when he was a bank robber.[8] He asks God for his "trusty .44" to persuade bankers to "put that bonus money back where it belongs".[20] Cooder discussed the character's perspective in an interview on BBC Radio 4's Today, stating "[T]he point here is that Jesse James was a primitive white man from the 19th Century. And in those days the hero was a one-man, one-gun hero. It's a very popular American myth. But what Jesse doesn't realise [in the song] is that while he's been up in heaven, the forces massed against him [...] He can't overcome the growth of the corporate, military-industrial equation. He can't walk down Wall Street and shoot up the place. No-one would even pay attention to him. The hero is outnumbered and outgunned. The wagons are circling, but what's he going to do? What's anyone going to do?"[22]
"Quick Sand" is a shuffling rock song that addresses the plight of illegal immigrants entering Arizona.[8] It follows six migrants travelling through the extreme climate of the Sonoran Desert to reach Devil's Highway in an attempt to cross the Mexico – United States border.[4][22] They journey from Tamaulipas and through the mountains along Devil's Highway. Partway into the journey, the migrants are abandoned by their coyote guide and subsequently lose one another one by one.[23] They experience thirst, hunger, injury, and fear, culminating with the only two surviving migrants being turned away by a vigilante at the border.[4] Cooder said of the route's background and the narrative in an interview, "[I]t's been a migrant trail for 200 years. People go out there and try to do it on foot, but if you make one mistake and go five minutes out of your way, you become disorientated and dehydrated. And they find these mummified bodies out there. The heat has just baked them through. And the people who live through it often refer to having a vision of the Virgin of Guadalupe flying overhead. This is a very common vision when the dehydration sets in."[22] Featuring guitar flourishes and countrypolitan strings,[13] "Dirty Chateau" follows an exchange between a reckless rich man with a big house and his maid, who comes from a community of farm workers.[20]
"Humpty Dumpty World" incorporates the marimba with light reggae and Mariachi influences.[3][24] The song's lyrics are sung from the perspective of God, who deplores the world He created.[20] He makes note of incitive politicians and craven television commentators, and views it as "a ball of confusion" in the chorus line,[14] "I thought I had built upon a solid rock / But it’s just a Humpty Dumpty World".[20] "Christmas Time This Year" is an anti-war song with a Mexican polka style,[8] with Flaco Jiménez on accordion and Cooder on bajo sexto.[7] Composed as a corrido,[25] the song is about wounded soldiers returning home for Christmas,[26] with dismal lyrics set incongruously to an upbeat Mexican melody.[10] Cooder wrote the song in response to the Walter Reed Army Medical Center neglect scandal and previous stories of neglected soldiers returning from the Iraq War.[9] In "Baby Joined the Army", a young man laments the departure of his girlfriend, who became uninterested in her town and enlisted in the army with the assurance that "If I get killed in battle, I still get paid."[20] "Lord Tell Me Why" is a gospel song with a rolling funk groove,[8] sung from the perspective of a lower class White man who has become disillusioned with the American dream.[24][27] His ironic lyrics ask in the chorus, "Lord tell me why a white man / Ain't worth nothin' in this world no more."[8] The guitar-based "I Want My Crown" was recorded with an 11-piece band and has an aggressive blues style,[8] rumba-rock groove, and growling vocals.[24] The song is an indictment of politicians as "Judas men" who sided with oil barons and Republicans,[24] and their greed that leads to war.[12] "I Want My Crown" has been described by one writer as a "Mephistopheles-as-Right-winger character study".[13]
"John Lee Hooker for President" is a blues song in which Cooder narrates as American blues musician John Lee Hooker visiting the White House.[2][8] Adopting Hooker's style and laconic vocal tone, he decides to run for the presidency after disliking what he observed in his visit, naming Jimmy Reed as Vice President,[8] Little Johnny Taylor as Secretary of State,[14] and proposing to have "nine fine-lookin' womens on the Supreme Court".[15] According to Cooder, the song was inspired by blues musician Gus Cannon's 1927 song "Can You Blame the Colored Man", a satirical piece about Booker T. Washington's invitation to the White House by President Theodore Roosevelt in 1901.[5] "Simple Tools" is a Tex-Mex ballad about the contentment of leading a simple lifestyle,[26] with references to the decline in traditional manual skills and the view of automated work as unfulfilling.[28] Featuring a resounding mix of mandolin and guitar,[20] "If There Is a God" is a satirical narrative about an afterlife in which Heaven is restricted by a government bill to the wealthy.[24] Its lyrics criticize redistricting and Republican Party legislature.[8] The song references "The Bourgeois Blues" by blues and folk musician Lead Belly.[24] In "No Hard Feelings", Cooder sings from the perspective of a lowly prospector who scolds businessmen for dealing with land exclusively in business terms.[24] He dismisses the rich and elite as "ripples" in history and is willing to tolerate them provided that they avoid conflict.[26]
The album was released by Nonesuch Records on August 30, 2011, in the United States.[18] It was released in the United Kingdom on September 5,[3] and on September 9 in other European countries.[29] Its vinyl LP release was on September 13.[18] The album's lead single, "Quicksand", was released as a digital download on June 29, 2010.[4] Cooder donated the proceeds from its sales to the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund.[4] The single's cover artwork, a piece called Nuthin' to See Here, Keep on Movin'!, was designed by visual artist Vincent Valdez, a frequent collaborator with Cooder.[30] Valdez contributed photography to the album's liner booklet.[7] Cooder performed with a 17-piece band at the Great American Music Hall in San Francisco, California on August 31 and September 1.[18] However, he was not satisfied with the shows' promotional aspect, and elaborated on it as part of his general disillusionment with the music industry in an interview for The Australian, stating:
We had a 16-piece band and we played great shows to 700 people a night. But none of them bought CDs. None of them. They had a good time but they weren't motivated to buy CDs. I don't understand it because I came up in the time of records. Back then the business ran. You still got the tunes out. It was a crooked business, you could get cheated and there could be crooked accounting, but I still prefer it to this new thing where there is no connection to the audience through radio or retail.[5]—Ry Cooder
The album debuted at number five on the US Billboard Top Folk Albums chart in the week of September 24, 2011.[31] It charted at number 123 on the Billboard 200 and number 28 on the Top Rock Albums.[32] The album also charted at number 15 on the Billboard Tastemaker Albums,[31] a chart that ranks top-selling albums "based on an influential panel of indie stores and small regional chains."[33]
In the United Kingdom, Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down debuted at number 26 on the UK Albums Chart, selling 6,000 copies in its first week.[34] It spent two weeks on the chart.[35] In Belgium, the album debuted at number 31 on the Ultratop 50 Albums. It peaked at number 21 and spent four weeks on the chart.[36] The album entered at number 24 and spent five weeks on the Mega Album Top 100 chart in the Netherlands.[37] In Norway, it debuted at number 13 on the VG-lista Top 40 Albums. It peaked at number nine and spent five weeks on the chart.[38] In Ireland, the album reached number 26 and spent four weeks on the Irish Albums Chart.[39]
| Professional ratings | |
|---|---|
| Review scores | |
| Source | Rating |
| Allmusic | [8] |
| Robert Christgau | (A–)[25] |
| The Daily Telegraph | [10] |
| The Guardian | [17] |
| The Independent | [24] |
| Mojo | [40] |
| The Observer | [12] |
| PopMatters | (8/10)[21] |
| Q | [19] |
| Uncut | [41] |
Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down received general acclaim from music critics.[42] At Metacritic, which assigns a weighted mean rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics, the album received an average score of 92, based on 14 reviews, which indicates "universal acclaim".[42] Allmusic editor Thom Jurek cited it as "the most overtly political album Ry Cooder has ever released, and one of his funniest, most musically compelling ones, too."[8] MusicOMH's Daniel Paton complimented Cooder's incorporation of traditional musical styles and stated, "For the most part, Pull Up Some Dust... is highly satisfying satire (although also often sensitive and affecting), combining Cooder’s transparent love for a wide range of roots music with his engagement with politics."[3] Martin Chilton of The Daily Telegraph praised its songs as "stunning" and dubbed it "one of the best albums of a distinguished career."[10] Hal Horowitz of American Songwriter commented that Cooder's "working class messages are enhanced by sharp musical chops".[16] Terry Staunton of Record Collector called the album "thought-provoking at every turn and elegantly wrapped in a dizzying array of musically schizophrenic paper" and commended Cooder's "keen observational eye", stating "Cooder's deft grip on American vernacular music infuses what could be a pretty sombre journey with some dazzling jumps in style."[28]
Chicago Sun-Times writer Mary Houlihan gave the album three-and-a-half out of four stars, calling it "an album that matters" and Cooder "a modern-day Woody Guthrie".[14] Phil Sutcliffe of Mojo complimented Cooder's own musical influences and "trenchant commentary", noting "the spirit of Woody Guthrie".[40] The New Zealand Herald's Graham Reid gave the album a five out of five rating and praised Cooder's "old styles and politics".[11] Neil Spencer of The Observer described it as "a fierce state-of-the-nation album" and called Cooder "a Woody Guthrie for our times."[12] Robin Denselow of The Guardian called the album "magnificent" and "as refreshing, brave and original as his early recordings in the 70s."[17] Andy Gill of The Independent dubbed it "his best effort by far since Chavez Ravine" and perceived "a dark parade of familiar Cooder figures [...] But almost everywhere one looks, Cooder finds a new twist on these old rivalries."[24] Nigel Williamson of Uncut dubbed it "one of his best albums ever".[41] BBC Music's Andy Fyfe commented that "this is about as good and sustained a riposte to the grubby, grabbing times we live in as any artist has mustered, which makes it essential listening."[26]
In his consumer guide for MSN Music, critic Robert Christgau gave the album an A– rating,[25] indicating "the kind of garden-variety good record that is the great luxury of musical micromarketing and overproduction."[43] Christgau commented that "Cooder has brought his longstanding obsession with the Great Depression into the present, where it unfortunately, tragically, enragingly belongs", adding that the album "doesn't rock, and it shouldn't. But it rollicks, skanks, and two-steps just fine."[25] Philip Majorins of PopMatters commented that the album "may not be a seamless narrative, but the themes are clear. Ry Cooder plays the part of the prophet flawlessly".[21] Majorins also commented on its sales potential, viewing that it would not have a significant impact due to commercial tastes and a "cynical" cultural climate, but wrote in conclusion, "Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down could have tremendous cathartic power for [those] who are aware of history and its knack for repeating itself. For those who are willing, this is a good place to start an education."[21] Peter Kane of Q described its music as "the heartening sounds of an old master at work."[19]
Uncut ranked the album number 20 on its list of Top 50 Albums of 2011.[44] Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down was nominated for a Grammy Award for Best Americana Album, set to be presented at the 54th Grammy Awards in 2012.[45]
All songs written and composed by Ry Cooder.
| No. | Title | Length |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | "No Banker Left Behind" | 3:36 |
| 2. | "El Corrido de Jesse James" | 4:17 |
| 3. | "Quick Sand" | 3:17 |
| 4. | "Dirty Chateau" | 5:29 |
| 5. | "Humpty Dumpty World" | 4:18 |
| 6. | "Christmas Time This Year" | 2:49 |
| 7. | "Baby Joined the Army" | 6:35 |
| 8. | "Lord Tell Me Why" (co-written by Jim Keltner) | 3:01 |
| 9. | "I Want My Crown" | 2:37 |
| 10. | "John Lee Hooker for President" | 6:08 |
| 11. | "Dreamer" | 5:05 |
| 12. | "Simple Tools" | 5:07 |
| 13. | "If There's a God" | 3:06 |
| 14. | "No Hard Feelings" | 5:52 |
Credits for Pull Up Some Dust and Sit Down adapted from liner notes.[7]
|
|
| Chart (2011) | Peak position |
|---|---|
| Austrian Albums Chart[29] | 74 |
| Belgian Albums Chart (Flanders)[36] | 21 |
| Dutch Albums Chart[37] | 24 |
| Finnish Albums Chart[46] | 40 |
| Irish Albums Chart[39] | 18 |
| Italian Albums Chart[47] | 54 |
| New Zealand Albums Chart[48] | 28 |
| Norwegian Albums Chart[38] | 9 |
| Spanish Albums Chart[49] | 77 |
| Swedish Albums Chart[50] | 12 |
| Swiss Albums Charts[51] | 64 |
| UK Albums Chart[35] | 26 |
| US Billboard 200[32] | 123 |
| US Billboard Top Folk Albums[31] | 5 |
| US Billboard Top Rock Albums[32] | 28 |
|
||||||||